Let’s Play With Data: The Management’s Pick
This article is submitted by JVALZ via Email and may contain his personal views towards the data he gathered. Thank you JVALZ for the article!
この記事はJVALZさんからメールで届いたものです。JVALZさんが集めたデータには個人的な観点が含まれている可能性があります。JVALZさん、記事をありがとうございます！
Can we guess which members the management picked for senbatsu the most within the 91 members that have worked for and those that are currently active in JKT48? Well it’s not easy to tell, but if we look closely into some data, there are some clues popping up and ready to be analyzed.
Let’s take a look into these ‘look-complicated-but-trust-me-it’s-not’ table. I compiled all the management picked senbatsu data only. So in this table, I excluded the senbatsu data from Gingham Check single because it might not directly picked by the management.
- Out of the historically 91 total members, only 33 members that have ever been picked by the management as senbatsu members.
- In 2013, a total of 26 members were picked by the management to fill up the senbatsu list . In 2014, they slimmed the list by selecting ‘only’ 21 members.
- There were 8 members that they always picked in 2013, they were: Melody, Haruka, Nabilah, Shanju, Ve, Yupi, Naomi, and Rona. Or in other words, the 2013 JKT48 ace members as regarded by the management.
- Too bad for Rona, she is never selected by the management for any single in 2014. Alas, she also failed in Gingham Check general election. However, there were 10 members that the management always picked in 2014 in every chance they could, they were: Melody, Haruka, Nabilah, Shanju, Ve, Yupi, Naomi, Kinal, Viny, and Dhike. Adding Kinal, Viny, and Dhike to the list, but Rona has to go out.
- Always strong on any ‘voting competition’ (only to be lost in Calendar Senbatsu 2015) and one of the senbatsu members in Gingham Check, Jeniffer Hanna also had some bad luck when it came to management pick for the A-Side single. She is never selected by the management in 2014.
- Yona, Ghaida, and Thalia had such a turnaround fate for them. Never been selected as senbatsu member in 2013, they were selected twice in 2014. If we include the Gingham Check senbatsu, they almost in every senbatsu list in 2014.
- Last, but not least, there are 7 members that are always selected by the management in every single (excluding Gingham Check), they are: Melody, Haruka, Nabilah, Shanju, Ve, Yupi, and Naomi. We can safely say that currently, those are the management top picks, the “Management’s Kami-Seven of JKT48.” The Seven True Aces? JOT’s Brave Seven? Your call now. What do you think?
JKT48で活動したことがあるメンバーそして現在活動しているメンバーの計91人の中で、運営選抜された回数が最も多いメンバーが誰かわかりますか？簡単には答えられないでしょうが、いくつかのデータをよく見るとその手がかりが浮かびあがり、分析の用意ができました。
以下の｢ややこしく見えるけど実はそうでもない｣表をご覧ください。運営が選抜したメンバーのデータだけを集めてみました。ギンガムチェックは直接の運営選抜ではないため、そのデータはこの表から除いてあります。
- 歴史的に合計91人にのぼるメンバーから、運営が選抜メンバーとして選んだのは33人だけです。
- 2013年は運営により合計26人のメンバーが選抜リストに入りました。2014年にそのリストはほんの21人にスリム化されました。
- 2013年は選抜常連が8人。それはメロディ、はるか、ナビラ、シャンジュ、フェランダ、ユッピ、ナオミ、ロナ。言い換えれば、運営による2013年エースメンバーです。
- 残念なのはロナ。2014年のロナはどのシングルにも選ばれていません。悲しいことにロナはギンガムチェックの一般による選抜（選挙）にも選ばれませんでした。しかし、2014年の運営選抜常連は10人いました。メロディ、はるか、ナビラ、シャンジュ、フェランダ、ユッピ、ナオミ、キナル、フィニ、ディクがリストに上がり、ロナが外れてしまいました。
- ｢投票争い｣では常に強く（負けは2015カレンダー選抜だけ）ギンガムチェックの選抜メンバーだったジェニファー・ハンナも、シングルA面の運営選抜となると運に恵まれませんでした。2014年はハンナは一度も運営選抜に入っていないんです。
- ヨナ、ガイダ、タタはそれとは逆。2013年は選抜に選ばれなかったものの、2014年は2回選ばれています。ギンガムチェック選抜を入れれば、2014年彼女たちはほとんど毎回選抜リストに入っています。
- 大事なことを一つ。どのシングル（ギンガムチェックを除く）でも常に選ばれたメンバーが7人います。メロディ、はるか、ナビラ、シャンジュ、フェランダ、ユッピ、ナオミです。今は彼女たちが運営がトップに選ぶ｢JKT48の運営神7｣と言って大丈夫でしょう。7人の真エース？JOT自信の7人？さあ皆さんの番ですよ。どう思いますか？
Japanese Translation by Japarta
The Chosen 7
That kinda have a nice ring to it hahaha:))
Hmm, ya know, I still remember the old running gag on this website regarding “The Chosen One”
owhh.. yeah.. that one..
Om bekkur finally going international. Cheers…
Semoga artikel-artikel lainnya juga bisa naik tayang di stuff…,
7 eleven
Fark
Sapta dewi?
That sounds nice too with a touch of local.
this is really interesting! feel bad about rona though. i hope they give her another shot in 2015 senbatsu.
i don’t see why they shouldn’t. especially since they gave her a solo song in the 3rd anniversary concert, and since rona is getting better known after the bad-assery Honda BeAT CMs
Yep, 2014 is not a good year for Rona. Let see at the next single, whether she will be selected by the management or not? If not, I hope JOT will give her, at least, solo single pathway.
Rona is too good to be neglected.
Out of those 7 management favorites, only Naomi who looks like she doesn’t have strong enough power in fan-voting event wise. Even though she managed to participate in 2013 PDRS but she failed in 2014 Senbatsu Calendar, 2014 PDRS, 2014 Senbatsu Sousenkyo and 2015 Senbatsu Calendar.
Well, recently Naomi has managed to sell out some of her Kazefu HS sessions even before the day of Kazefu HS event but it’s too premature to say that this surge will continue on to 2015 Senbatsu Sousenkyo.
Yep, Naomi is indeed the ‘weakest’ one from those 7 management favorites in terms of fan-voting event. The second one is Yupi, which only managed to ‘won’ the voting in 2013 PDRS and placed 12th in 2014 senbatsu sousenkyo. Vienny and Yona from K3 have better record in terms of fans-voting event.
The rest of them are considerably strong in fans-voting event, especially Haruka (5 from 5), Melody (4 from 5), and veranda (4 from 5).
Let’s see in the next senbatsu sousenkyo. Can Naomi turn her fate? It will be really fun to watch.
and, can someone compile CM ‘senbatsu’ also?
I think its interesting too…
or
goes to ‘Japan’ senbatsu? lol
Show the data all about management’s pick in any event…
had a strange feeling that me have read this before
but forgot where..
Since JKT48 released 1st single ‘River’, there are 5 members that are always selected by the management and fans in every single, they are Melody, Ve, Haruka, Nabilah and Shania.
Tujuh Member Harimau / Seven Tiger Member,
yeah, a pun on that tv series… :v
My Kami-Seven would probably be Melody, Ve, Haruka, Shanju, Beby, Nabilah and Vienny
ikr, melody – the ace
ve – hardcore fans
haruka – famous bcs ini talk show
shania – the “mayuyu”
nabilah – hardcore fans
yupi – team K ace
naomi – team K captain
first of all I want to say sorry to all yupi fans, but I think she doesn’t deserved to be included in every single due to her dancing and singing capabilities which are very so so. well maybe she deserved at some, but not all… sorry but I really want to say this
IMHO, that’s the beauty of idol group. maybe you can’t sing or dance, but if you catch fans attention, you got your ticket to popularity. let’s face it, in jkt48, only a few can really sing (ayen, sendy, noella, stella (?)… )…and their dancing skill is…well…mediocre at best (if you compare it to “real” pro). so yeah, it’s just that you don’t need any reason at all to support someone in idol group!
if she’s popular enough, then why she can’t?