Jakarta-Born Girl Joins AKB48-Inspired Girl Radical

Richardson Kilis

Richardson H. Kilis is a U.S.-educated Indonesianist who studies the relationship of technology and cultural exchange.

16 Responses

  1. tomomo says:

    Wew, the Asia concept is tried by the western music……..
    Can the concept become success?
    Well, let’s see for next few month maybe…..

  2. abaone94 says:

    Interesting! The first western style mega-group.

    Looking at the ‘members’ however, it appears they are in the 18’s to their 20’s… and apparently will focus more on vocal abilities instead of emphasizing dances.

    If they get big, then they will naturally became AKB48’s and K-Pop groups rival.

  3. Tomo says:

    Good vocals. But no unique choreograph like 48. Does it attract some one?

    • benimaru says:

      it will :)

      because they had the concept, and the vision of what will becoming of the group they made..

      unlike the indonesian “male version” of 48 group :lol: :lol: :lol:

      • Tomo says:

        I knew that AKB had their tour to visit New York City and Los Angels. If AKS will decide to flanchise the 48 concept to the US local cities, such as SAT48 (Siatle), IDP48 (Indianapolis), BST48 (Boston), sure LAX48 (Los Angels) and NYC48 (New York City) so on and on. 8-O Will the 48 concept installed the US local cities girls groups defeat this kind of the US girls? :wink:

    • Tomo-san, you should be aware that a large segment of the American audience has low tolerance for these types of concepts which market female sexuality. Jezebel.com, a popular feminist blog, recently slammed the concept of the group and called it an embarrassment. With that said, it’s not uncommon in the United States to see someone receiving a lot of credit for denouncing other people’s idea and work. Girl Radical probably has a more difficult uphill battle in the American market than JKT48 in Indonesia.

      • Tomo says:

        Richardson-san. Appriciate for your advice. I can understand you thought. Probably as you all can see, when the music video of “Heavy Rotation (by, sure, AKB48)” was released, among many adult Japanese persons, it was said that the girls were sexualily squeezed by the project stakeholders. My wife is the one of them. She says that she can smell the money and imatured sex from 48 project. Also you have already watched the video of CNN’s “Talk Asia”. Yasushi Akimoto was hounded down by a female interviewer. She asked “Do you squeeze sex from young girls?”. Akimono repled under the pressure of nedessity, “It is an art”. When Akimoto’s a white limousine arrived at AKB48 theater, the interviewer got down. And Akimoto reached his hand to her hand. But she dinied. Please understand that I don’t want to dirt 48 and JKT48. I just want to explan various thoughts are here in Japan also.

  4. AsianKoe says:

    wow, very interesting. :)
    but I cant imagine when some western girls doing kawaiiness dancing like the asian girls.
    OK, just wait n see.
    Goodluck America :wink:

    • abaone94 says:

      i reckon they won’t do exactly what AKB had done.

      Idol-ish acts and dances are pretty much unfamiliar on the west. At this time, if this Girl Radical is to survive, they must cope with the atmosphere of American music industry, instead of moving up to more AKB-ish.

      That means different concepts, different methods, different images.

      While AKB had a more fixed concept, JC and that songwriter had to think an entirely new one to face American culture. That’s the real challenge of his producership.

      See if JC can be the next Aki-P 8)

  5. Adolf says:

    18 is the youngest age? Something to do with child law related or labor law?

  6. Annie Tjia says:

    I don’t really have anything to say about this, I guess I still need to see how it’ll be going. It’s too early to make any comment, because honestly I don’t mind if a group is created in inspiration of 48group. Another story if they start to exagerate everything just for popularity and no quality, well…

  7. PN03 says:

    Time will tell if they gonna be…

  8. Sunred says:

    nice try ‘murica.
    next time, please don’t. stick to burgers and fries.

  9. HERMAN says:

    My opinion: Their looks are too bi**hy and their faces are too old to be an AKB48-cloned girlband. Perhaps the guy from ‘N Sync was tired of AKB48 and K-Pop-cloned and swore that he could do better than those idiotic plagiarists.(Such as ***29). But, sadly, he didn’t. Me? I’ll stick with JKT48.

  10. Cl4p Trap says:

    Oh USA, land of freedom and home for the brave. Feminist, fascist, atheist, and etc all available in USA. So why not.

  11. athiegna says:

    If I look more, it seems they adopt the concept of “each member has her own personality and interest” of 48family, not about japanese-idol-definition and kawaiiness, plus it mixed with some K-Pop touch.
    The ‘idol’ figure in america is pretty different from asia, maybe we find the girls from 48 are ideal and perfect, but I think from american perspective, they may find girls from 48 are cute but lame and weak. They prefer strong figure to be idolized, and I think they prefer more rebelious figure not the cutie ones and the angel-type. Remember Destiny’s child? TLC? Or, to be extreme, look at Madonna, Rihanna, or.. Lady Gaga.
    That’s my opinion.
    Let’s see if they will survive.. who knos if they could be the next Spice Girls, the most popular western girlband?